Why invest 12-15 mill in a catcher when Pinto has shown obvious signs of being ready to take over.
With the extreme need for SP all available $ needs to be used there for craps sakes.
Also from this story....
I would think if the Twins signed another catcher, it would be limited to a one-year deal, and Saltalamachia is going to get a multi-year deal. But I'm OK with the Twins not wanting Pinto to get more AB before they trust him too much. He only had 75 plate appearances in both AAA and the majors.Quote:
A separate source said to also keep an eye on free-agent A.J. Pierzynski's situation, that he'd be a good one-year stop-gap option until Josmil Pinto is ready to take over as the main option.
Maybe a catcher for 1 or 2 years, but Twins have more pressing problems and I would rather the money be spent there(starting pitching)
The Twins have about 60-70 million to spend this off-season, if you follow the promised 52% of revenue. This will be enough for 3 pitchers and a couple of position players. Just glad that Butera is gone, because he would start next season.
The Twins aren't going to win in 2014 and Pinto will be 25. Just let him play and see what happens.
Also Hermann can platoon against some of the RHP as well.
It is critical that the Twins add a catcher that can defend. Ideally it would be a starter.
There are doubts that Pinto can handle the job defensively. Doumit caught far too many games this year. He will catch more next year.
if the Twins go into next season and find out Pinto is a significant defensive liability, where will they turn? Even a defense only catcher like Butera costs a premium during the seasons
Look at it from a free agent pitchers point of view. A pitcher like Hughes or Johnson are going to look to build their value towards the next contract. They need to put themselves in a good situation. Any agent is going to make them aware of the significant decrease in K/BB ratios with Doumit catching. They will be aware of the the pitch framing data. Ryan has publicized the concerns about Pinto's defense. Why sign into that situation and damage your future value?
Catcher needs to be an early priority this winter.
Personally, I'd be fine with a platoon of Pinto & Hermann behind the plate next season. If one or both totally bomb, I have no doubt that they could scramble and come up with some AAAA defensive whiz to finish out 2014 and address the issue next winter. I'd MUCH rather see the Twins target their spending on starting pitching and one semi-impact bat play one of about five other positions. With Mauer at 1B, Arcia at one of the OF or DH spots & Dozier at 2B, an upgrade could be found for anywhere else.
Saltalamacchia would be a very nice signing assuming the price is right. He is good defensively and provides a nice amount of "pop" behind the dish.
If Pinto proves to be an effective major league catcher (Bat-Sure, Defense...meh, lets see) then you have what they call a "good" problem. Also, has the Drew Butera era not shown us the value in having multiple solid options behind the dish?
AJ wouldn't be a bad stop gap, but if you go that route then Pinto basically needs to become an everyday catcher, otherwise moving Mauer does nothing except open up a huge whole.
The Twins have plenty of payroll and Salty is still on the right side of 30, give him a 3 year deal and if Pinto pushes him out of a job you can always find a trade partner.
SS- There really aren't any.
3B- Isn't Sano going to be manning 3B by June? What impact bat will sign a one year deal?
OF- Hicks and Buxton will be up soon, so again, who do you sign? Willingham already takes take of the one year stop gap "power bat"
The Twins frankly aren't going to sign more then 3 pitchers absolute max total, and at the very least one would be a bargin bin signing (if not two)
You can have enough money to sign a couple decent contracts on pitchers, as well as Salty and another OF if you need. I like Pinto, but there is prob a reason he DH'ed so much in the minors, I really don't see what anyone sees in Herrmann that makes them think he is anything more then a backup.
If the Twins really want a stop gap veteran catcher for a year, what's wrong with Doumit?
Money spent for a catcher = money wasted. It's not like Pinto has to bat .300, he simply has to hit as well as Plouffe and be "OK" at catcher. The need is pitchi put all of the free-agent money there. Signing multiple barrel scraping is worse than one or two of the best pitchers that can be had by the Twins. Catcher? Pinto, Hermann, Doumit and whoever is at Rochester are more than enough options. The need to is to challenge the next wave to see if they belong, not spend aimlessly on some washed-up veteran who would be replaced anyway. Play Pinto.
Unless the Twins get McCann or Salty, there is no reason whatsoever to throw money at a catcher. A.J. is not a serious contender. Good lord.
The best money we could spend to help the pitching staff is a good defensive catcher. Pinto looked far below average defensively. Watch St. Louis. They get a lot of credit for having so many good young pitchers. I think it helps them tremendously to pitch to Molina. The twins need Gibson and Meyer to be pitching well in the majors next year to have a chance to put together a decent starting rotation. Signing a good defensive catcher in my opinion is more important than signing a starting pitcher.
A good defensive catcher is not more valuable than an above average to good starting pitcher. Not even close. Again, Herrmann and Pinto average out to an average defensive catcher.
It makes no sense not to bring in a veteran catcher to split the job at least 50/50 with Pinto. All kinds of catchers are out there, for all kinds of prices. A two year deal until Turner is ready will work just fine.
Also, Turner has been wrongly labeled as a Butera clone since he is outstanding defensively. At .372 he was the #1 hitter for a team which has made the NCAA playoffs 11 of the past 13 years and #4 in the SEC. Teams that didn't like his hit tool didn't draft him, a team that did, did as per usual. The Twins were linked to every top catcher in the draft. Turner fit their draft board.