Page 3 of 3 FirstFirst 123
Results 41 to 53 of 53

Thread: BaseballAmerica top 100 drops today

  1. #41
    Senior Member Big-Leaguer Twins Twerp's Avatar
    Posts
    607
    Like
    6
    Liked 31 Times in 20 Posts
    Arcia is the kind of prospect that doesn't rank high, but the kind that you KNOW will make it. He may not be a perrenial all-star, but he is going to give you a great bat. I would take a system full of Arcia's rather than a system full of "lofty, toolsy" guys who haven't put the tools together. Sometimes those guys win you the lottery, but sometimes those guys end up being punch lines. Arcia is going to hit close to .300 with 20+ homers. He is going to have a pretty good arm and is going to be below average fielder. Sounds like a pretty legit player to me.

    For some reason, an entity like BaseballAmerica and Keith Law enjoy higher ceiling guys than sure thing guys. If you look at baseballamerica's list, the top is full of guys who were drafted last year (Buxton, Gausman, etc.). Towards the bottom of the top 100 you see much safer picks with guys who are close to the bigs and some who have even seen some time. If I were to do a list, I would lean more towards the Major League ready guys and less towards the projection type guys in low A.

  2. #42
    Senior Member All-Star
    Posts
    1,532
    Like
    0
    Liked 70 Times in 48 Posts
    Alex wimmers was a safer, close to the bigs type, and how has that turned out? The reason why arcia is so "low", even though 41 is pretty darn good, has more to do with his position than his ability. Heck, the only right fielders I count ahead of arcia are myers, taveras, soler and yelchy so he is in some pretty elite company.

    The fact is a .300ba/20~hr average right fielder is a ~2 WAR player. While a Cf, Ss, or C with half the bat of Arcia is a ~4 WAR player. while WAR is a very flawed stat even the eye test can tell you elite guys up the middle are significantly harder to find.

  3. #43
    Senior Member All-Star
    Posts
    4,609
    Like
    512
    Liked 214 Times in 147 Posts
    How is 41 in the entire minors low?

  4. #44
    Senior Member All-Star
    Posts
    1,532
    Like
    0
    Liked 70 Times in 48 Posts
    Quote Originally Posted by mike wants wins View Post
    How is 41 in the entire minors low?
    Exactly. 41 in the entire minors for a right fielder is anything but low.

  5. #45
    Senior Member All-Star Badsmerf's Avatar
    Posts
    1,508
    Like
    12
    Liked 31 Times in 19 Posts
    Blog Entries
    6
    Psuedo you brought up a very good point. I'm not going to fully retract my statement since I'm obviously higher on Arcia than many. I think he should be in the top 20. For the 100th time, his defense is above average, that makes a big difference. Positions matter little to me since most of the CF or SS prospects don't stick there.... obviously why there is a shortage of quality SS and CF in the MLB right now. I believe Arcia could easily be a 5 WAR player, putting him in the top 11 OF in the MLB (based on WAR alone). So yes, I think 41 is too low.
    Do or do not. There is no try.

  6. #46
    Head Moderator All-Star glunn's Avatar
    Posts
    4,510
    Like
    2,347
    Liked 293 Times in 165 Posts
    Blog Entries
    1
    Quote Originally Posted by grover738 View Post
    A few things I noticed from the list - there were only six 80 (the highest ranking) given out, and two are Twins prospects.

    Gerrit Cole's (Pirates P) Fastball
    Miguel Sano's Power
    Byron Buxton's Speed
    Billy Hamilton's (Reds of/ss) Speed
    Bruce Rendon's (Tigers P) Fastball
    Roman Quinn's (Phillies SS) Speed

    Pretty cool that the only 80 for Power was Sano's.

    Anybody else surprised that Sano got a 75 for his arm? I saw him last year when Beloit visited Cedar Rapids, he definetly has a cannon, but a 75? Higher than Buxton or Hicks?

    Also, Sano was the only player with two separate ratings greater than 70.

    Can't wait to go down to CR this summer. Great park, cheap tickets, cheap beer, players are accessible, I can't encourage people to make the trip enough!
    With his speed and arm, maybe Sano should end up in right field?

  7. #47
    Senior Member All-Star PseudoSABR's Avatar
    Posts
    1,762
    Like
    138
    Liked 110 Times in 67 Posts
    Quote Originally Posted by Badsmerf View Post
    Psuedo you brought up a very good point. I'm not going to fully retract my statement since I'm obviously higher on Arcia than many. I think he should be in the top 20. For the 100th time, his defense is above average, that makes a big difference. Positions matter little to me since most of the CF or SS prospects don't stick there.... obviously why there is a shortage of quality SS and CF in the MLB right now. I believe Arcia could easily be a 5 WAR player, putting him in the top 11 OF in the MLB (based on WAR alone). So yes, I think 41 is too low.
    I also think his bat is a bit better than BA is letting on, as well. But when looking at the list of the guys above him, it's fair company.

    Scouting--and I'm aware of the blanket generalization I'm about to make--just loves tools. They also love pedigree (which might as well be defined as "how long have we liked this guy"). So I understand why some higher profile, skill position players get higher ranking on prospect lists--whether those players end up being worth so much in the ML is a different question.

    Arcia was relatively unknown to the prominent, public scouting community (maybe my memory is wrong on this..) before he started to produce. He's a good defender, but he doesn't have lights out speed or a cannon arm or Sano power. He's got an incredible bat so far which will always be iffyier for scouts to quantify than any physical skill; everyone just seems scared to believe in him.
    Last edited by PseudoSABR; 02-22-2013 at 01:23 AM.

  8. #48
    Senior Member Double-A
    Posts
    192
    Like
    0
    Liked 10 Times in 7 Posts
    Quote Originally Posted by PseudoSABR View Post
    I also think his bat is a bit better than BA is letting on, as well. But when looking at the list of the guys above him, it's fair company.

    Scouting--and I'm aware of the blanket generalization I'm about to make--just loves tools. They also love pedigree (which might as well be defined as "how long have we liked this guy"). So I understand why some higher profile, skill position players get higher ranking on prospect lists--whether those players end up being worth so much in the ML is a different question.

    Arcia was relatively unknown to the prominent, public scouting community (maybe my memory is wrong on this..) before he started to produce. He's a good defender, but he doesn't have lights out speed or a cannon arm or Sano power. He's got an incredible bat so far which will always be iffyier for scouts to quantify than any physical skill; everyone just seems scared to believe in him.
    All I remember is that Sickels loved him.

  9. #49
    Senior Member Triple-A Steve Lein's Avatar
    Posts
    434
    Like
    8
    Liked 20 Times in 9 Posts
    Blog Entries
    2
    Quote Originally Posted by Badsmerf View Post
    For the 100th time, his defense is above average, that makes a big difference. Positions matter little to me since most of the CF or SS prospects don't stick there....
    I think you need to temper what your definition of "above average" defense is a bit. In Arcia's case, everything I see and read says he has enough arm for RF, but not really a "cannon," and will not impress anyone with his range or speed. Having the arm is nice, but we all know it has a far less impact on outfield defense than actually being able to run down fly balls. I'd put exactly "average" as his peak (which is to say if everything develops perfectly for him there, he will be an average RF defender)

    I highly recommend this site, run by Mark Anderson of Scout.com, and here's his write-up on Arcia: http://baseballprospectnation.com/20...aldo-arcia-of/

    As for your second sentence in my quote snippet, that's why the guys that do stay there (and have the other "tools" besides the defense to stay there) become the blue-chipper-top-10-in-all-of-baseball-prospects, so sorry, but position does matter.

    But I agree with the others, being ranked where Arcia is as a RF is not a slight to him and what he's done at all. It shows that most everyone believes he has a "plus" bat.
    Follow me on Twitter: @HangingSL
    Spring Training Regular since 2010.

  10. #50
    Senior Member All-Star
    Posts
    1,532
    Like
    0
    Liked 70 Times in 48 Posts
    Easily a 5 WAR player? Was there even a single 5 WAR right fielder last year? By WAR standards, which always ham strings RF/1B value, he would have to hit .330 ba/35+ homers/1000 OPS and be a well above defender. While i havent read that being his ceiling, i hope you are right! That. Would. Be. AWESOME. About the well above average defender part...

    Badsmerf where did you see he was an above average defender? I know when he was 18 he played a little center field but that's a long time ago. BA and Mayo have him at 50 defense because while he reads the ball well and has a plus arm he is a 40 runner. I can't find defensive grades from law/sickles, they are always too busy talking about his sexy swing, but maybe you read different? Maybe Seth had him at an above average defender? I'm not saying you are wrong, I'm just saying I haven't read it.

    Either way, I hope you are right and he becomes a top 25 player in all of baseball because our twinkies sure could use one.

  11. #51
    Senior Member Big-Leaguer Twins Twerp's Avatar
    Posts
    607
    Like
    6
    Liked 31 Times in 20 Posts
    A little off topic, but what is the Twins International cap for this year? Everyone had the same cap this year but I have read multiple times that this year and in future years the cap will be inversly related to teams records. That would obviously put the Twins at having the 4th highest cap on international signing. The penalties will be stiff for teams that go over that cap (the Rangers are an example as they were WAY over the cap).

  12. #52
    Super Moderator All-Star
    Posts
    3,419
    Like
    167
    Liked 309 Times in 184 Posts
    Blog Entries
    3
    Quote Originally Posted by Steve Lein View Post
    I think you need to temper what your definition of "above average" defense is a bit. In Arcia's case, everything I see and read says he has enough arm for RF, but not really a "cannon," and will not impress anyone with his range or speed. Having the arm is nice, but we all know it has a far less impact on outfield defense than actually being able to run down fly balls. I'd put exactly "average" as his peak (which is to say if everything develops perfectly for him there, he will be an average RF defender)

    I highly recommend this site, run by Mark Anderson of Scout.com, and here's his write-up on Arcia: http://baseballprospectnation.com/20...aldo-arcia-of/

    As for your second sentence in my quote snippet, that's why the guys that do stay there (and have the other "tools" besides the defense to stay there) become the blue-chipper-top-10-in-all-of-baseball-prospects, so sorry, but position does matter.

    But I agree with the others, being ranked where Arcia is as a RF is not a slight to him and what he's done at all. It shows that most everyone believes he has a "plus" bat.
    He was a centerfielder until he had to share an outfield with Aaron Hicks. I don't expect him to be Ben Revere in the corner, but for people to expect him to be an above average outfielder is hardly unrealistic. Perhaps he will continue to fill out and slow down a bit, who knows, but right now, he should slot into right as an above average defender. If Benson can work his bat out, he could be a gold glove calliber in left... With Hicks in center, that outfield defense is looking pretty good for the remainder of the decade.

  13. #53
    Senior Member All-Star Badsmerf's Avatar
    Posts
    1,508
    Like
    12
    Liked 31 Times in 19 Posts
    Blog Entries
    6
    Steve, a simple google search with Oswaldo Arcia and defense will provide you with numerous results stating he is an above average defender whom might taper to an average defender once he fills out. Considering he is 22, I think he has 5 years or so of being an above average fielder (RF to be specific). When his range starts to drop off hopefully he will be hitting 30+ HR's a year to make up for it.
    Do or do not. There is no try.

Page 3 of 3 FirstFirst 123

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •  
©2014 TwinsCentric, LLC. All Rights Reserved.
Interested in advertising with Twins Daily? Click here.